Lube-Tips Newsletter

    January 19, 2005
Sent to 36,873 worldwide

1. Gear Alignment Affects Lubrication

2. Rolling Element Bearing Contamination

3. Mixing Viscosity Grades

4. How Oil Life Cycle Costs Are Calculated

Today's Tip: Gear Alignment Affects Lubrication

Worm gearing alignment affects lubrication. If the worm is located off the worm gear centerline there may be entering corner contact. This wipes the lubricant off the worm gear teeth and the worm thread like a squeegee causing the mesh to be starved for lubricant. The resulting wear is progressive and almost always results in the need to replace both the worm and the worm gear.

An easy way to prevent this type of failure is to perform a contact pattern check when the worm gear and worm are installed or being replaced. Most text on worm gearing show both acceptable and unacceptable contact patterns for this unloaded condition. If in doubt, contact the worm gear drive vender or the drive manufacturer.

Oil analysis would show this condition as high levels of copper from the worm gear. The copper levels will increase over time rather than decrease as is the case for normal break in. Visual inspection would show wear on the worm gear tooth from the tip to the root at the edge of the tooth that see the thread entry into mesh. There may also be a transfer of bronze from the worm gear to the worm thread. (Submitted by Richard Dornfield, P.E., Staff Engineer, Walker Process Equipment. Thanks Richard.)

Join us for Oil Analysis I training and certification on February 8-10 in San Diego, CA. Other locations.

Each tip published will earn the sender $100. Submit your tip.


Reliability Professionals Wanted

We continue to face growing demands for maintenance managers, engineers, consultants, and technicians. If you have a background in reliability and maintenance, please us send at resumes@reliabilitycareers.com. And as always, all resumes are handled with the highest confidentiality.

We are actively looking for a Maintenance Manager at Michigan City, IN. This position is responsible for maintaining the plant's equipment and facilities, continued development of the associates, and delivery of maintenance services to the plant. BS in engineering required. Please send resume to resumes@reliabilitycareers.com.

Reliability Careers
www.ReliabilityCareers.com


Book Bits: Rolling Element Bearing Contamination


From "Lubrication Fundamentals"

Solid particles of any kind that are trapped between the rolling elements and raceways are the most frequent cause of shortened bearing life. Consequently, dirt should be kept out of bearings as much as possible, and lubricants should be changed before oxidation has progressed to the point where deposits begin to form. The use of oxidation-inhibited lubricants can greatly extend the period of time that lubricants may be left in service without excessive oxidation.

More information about the book "Lubrication Fundamentals"


Lube Trivia: Mixing Viscosity Grades

Test your knowledge and prepare for ICML lubrication and oil analysis certification.

QUESTION: When an SAE 20 is blended with an SAE 40, will the resulted viscosity be closer to SAE 30 or SAE 60?

Get the answer.


Q & A: How Oil Life Cycle Costs Are Calculated


"What is the meaning of "the life cycle cost of oil" and how is it calculated
?"

Sometimes a higher performance product costs less than a commodity-type product, even though the price is higher. To gauge whether this will be the case we should look at the product life cycle cost, rather than the purchase price.

The life cycle cost of oil is effectively the total long term use cost for a given product from oil change to oil change. There are a variety of indirect, but none-the-less valid, costs and time commitments that factor into an oil change, including the following:

1. Oil specification.

2. Oil purchase, including: purchase document generation and sending purchase document.

3. Cost of the oil itself.

4. Oil receipt and storage, including: tracking of shipment paperwork to affirm receipt and re-work for errors and omissions.

5. Invoice receipt, approval and payment (this item alone can add a lot to the real cost of plant lubrication).

6. Oil transfer to the user or the asset.

7. Oil disposal cost, if any.

8. Cost of labor associated with the oil change.

9. Cost of other materials associated with an oil change.

10. Cost of monitoring the new oil for the life of the oil.

11. Cost of degradation effect, including loss of oil strength, loss of filterability, loss of cleanliness, corrosion and corruption of mechanical surfaces.

12. Cost of machine downtime if there is any associated with the oil change.

There may be other costs that you could identify for your specific organization.

If you estimate each actual incremental cost or time requirement, apply a normalized labor rate for the time, and then add the various costs together, you could fairly accurately guess the total life cycle cost of an oil change at your facility. It is higher than you might expect.

While all of these items do not show up in the obvious as a line-item in the maintenance budget report (which is generally limited to the cost of the purchase itself, and is measure by cost per pound or cost per gallon), the costs are nonetheless absorbed by the organization and add to the total cost per item manufactured.

Mike Johnson, Noria Corporation

Submit a question | Discuss on Message Boards

Resources

 

Training Calendar

JANUARY 2005

Effective Contamination Control
25-26 Birmingham, AL

Machinery Lubrication I
20-21 Gdansk, Poland

Oil Analysis I
25-26 Monterrey, Mexico

Oil Analysis II
27-28 Monterrey, Mexico

 

FEBRUARY 2005

Machinery Lubrication I
14-15 Gaborone, Botswana
22-24 Point Lisas, Trinidad

Machinery Lubrication II
16-17 Gaborone, Botswana
24-25 Gdansk, Poland

Oil Analysis I
8-10 San Diego, CA
15-16 Sunninghill, Johannesburg, South Africa
23-24 San Juan, Puerto Rico
22-24 Daegu, Korea
23-24 Valencia, Venezuela

Oil Analysis II
17-18 Sunninghill, Johannesburg, South Africa

Oil Analysis – The Complete Course
8-10 Gdansk, Poland

Effective Mobile Equipment Lubrication
22-24 Reno, NV

Técnicas de Lubricación
17 Cartagena, Colombia
22 San Juan, Puerto Rico
22 Valencia, Venezuela
24 Santa Cruz, Bolivia

Análisis de Aceite para Equipo Móvil
15-16 Cartagena, Columbia


Lube-Tips is published weekly by:
Noria Corporation, 1328 E. 43rd Court, Tulsa, OK 74105 USA. (918) 749-1400

Because results will vary widely based on a number of factors, Noria Corporation cannot warrant the results of any material within this e-mail.

© 1998-2005 Noria Corporation

»Receive your own subscription to Lube-Tips

Other Resources:
»Lube-Tips Archives
»Machinery Lubrication Magazine
»Practicing Oil Analysis Magazine
»Bookstore
»Buyers Guide
»Dictionary